Pir, Imaginative Rascal // Toothy, Imaginary Friend (Commander) - Core +1/+1 Counters

Tyler Bucks
Mar 17, 2026
Budget Replacements for Doubling Season in Commander
Doubling Season is one of the most well known cards for Commander players. But it's expensive! Let's look at some cheaper alternatives.
Deck Filters
Archidekt
Commander Spellbook
Moxfield
Scryfall
MTGStocks
Forgotten Ancient
81%inclusion29 decks36 decks
72%synergy
Hardened Scales
78%inclusion28 decks36 decks
62%synergy
Simic Ascendancy
64%inclusion23 decks36 decks
51%synergy
Deepglow Skate
53%inclusion19 decks36 decks
50%synergy
Wizard Class
53%inclusion19 decks36 decks
47%synergy
Kami of Whispered Hopes
53%inclusion19 decks36 decks
45%synergy
Master Biomancer
50%inclusion18 decks36 decks
44%synergy
Ozolith, the Shattered Spire
50%inclusion18 decks36 decks
42%synergy
Chasm Skulker
47%inclusion17 decks36 decks
41%synergy
Branching Evolution
53%inclusion19 decks36 decks
41%synergy
Top Cards
Counterspell
64%inclusion23 decks36 decks
15%synergy
Growth Spiral
61%inclusion22 decks36 decks
16%synergy
Beast Within
56%inclusion20 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Herald of Secret Streams
53%inclusion19 decks36 decks
39%synergy
Inspiring Call
50%inclusion18 decks36 decks
36%synergy
Brainstorm
47%inclusion17 decks36 decks
33%synergy
Vorel of the Hull Clade
44%inclusion16 decks36 decks
36%synergy
Rampant Growth
44%inclusion16 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Fathom Mage
44%inclusion16 decks36 decks
37%synergy
Kodama's Reach
42%inclusion15 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Creatures
Managorger Hydra
42%inclusion15 decks36 decks
37%synergy
Evolution Sage
42%inclusion15 decks36 decks
32%synergy
Duskshell Crawler
42%inclusion15 decks36 decks
39%synergy
Prime Speaker Zegana
39%inclusion14 decks36 decks
29%synergy
Laboratory Maniac
39%inclusion14 decks36 decks
32%synergy
Kodama of the West Tree
33%inclusion12 decks36 decks
30%synergy
Zimone, Paradox Sculptor
31%inclusion11 decks35 decks
27%synergy
Llanowar Elves
31%inclusion11 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Rishkar, Peema Renegade
31%inclusion11 decks36 decks
26%synergy
Zegana, Utopian Speaker
28%inclusion10 decks36 decks
21%synergy
Kalonian Hydra
28%inclusion10 decks36 decks
25%synergy
Cankerbloom
28%inclusion10 decks36 decks
25%synergy
Gyre Sage
28%inclusion10 decks36 decks
21%synergy
Evolution Witness
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
21%synergy
Incubation Druid
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
17%synergy
Plaxcaster Frogling
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
21%synergy
Champion of Lambholt
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
20%synergy
Lorescale Coatl
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
24%synergy
Twenty-Toed Toad
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
20%synergy
Warden of the Grove
24%inclusion7 decks29 decks
22%synergy
Elvish Mystic
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
0%synergy
Loyal Guardian
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
20%synergy
Thrummingbird
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
17%synergy
Dreamtide Whale
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
19%synergy
Psychosis Crawler
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
16%synergy
Flux Channeler
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
17%synergy
Danny Pink
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
18%synergy
Ezuri, Stalker of Spheres
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
18%synergy
Birds of Paradise
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
-8%synergy
Bristly Bill, Spine Sower
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
14%synergy
Scavenging Ooze
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
14%synergy
Merfolk Skydiver
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
11%synergy
Zameck Guildmage
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
15%synergy
Ouroboroid
14%inclusion3 decks21 decks
10%synergy
Displacer Kitten
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
11%synergy
Fertilid
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
12%synergy
Disciple of Freyalise
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
9%synergy
Skatewing Spy
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
13%synergy
Hydroid Krasis
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Roalesk, Apex Hybrid
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
13%synergy
Rikku, Resourceful Guardian
13%inclusion3 decks24 decks
12%synergy
Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
9%synergy
Beast Whisperer
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Murkfiend Liege
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
-3%synergy
Renata, Called to the Hunt
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
10%synergy
Vigor
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
10%synergy
Spike Weaver
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
11%synergy
Spark Double
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Pollywog Prodigy
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Arwen, Weaver of Hope
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Instants
Rapid Hybridization
36%inclusion13 decks36 decks
9%synergy
Repulsive Mutation
36%inclusion13 decks36 decks
30%synergy
Essence Flux
36%inclusion13 decks36 decks
33%synergy
Arcane Denial
36%inclusion13 decks36 decks
14%synergy
Ghostly Flicker
33%inclusion12 decks36 decks
27%synergy
Pongify
31%inclusion11 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Planar Incision
31%inclusion11 decks36 decks
28%synergy
Negate
28%inclusion10 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Frantic Search
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
19%synergy
Ripples of Potential
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
15%synergy
An Offer You Can't Refuse
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
-1%synergy
Mutational Advantage
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
17%synergy
Tolarian Winds
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
22%synergy
Blur
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
17%synergy
Heroic Intervention
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
-11%synergy
Return of the Wildspeaker
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Invigorating Surge
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
16%synergy
Nature's Claim
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Reality Shift
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Slip Out the Back
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
13%synergy
Sink into Stupor
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Siren's Ruse
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
13%synergy
Opt
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Voidslime
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
9%synergy
Plasm Capture
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Return to Nature
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Snap
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Veil of Summer
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Snakeskin Veil
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Gaea's Gift
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Experimental Augury
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Solidarity of Heroes
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Displace
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Stubborn Denial
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Bioshift
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Fuel for the Cause
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Aetherize
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
-4%synergy
Tamiyo's Safekeeping
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Naturalize
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Overprotect
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Hunter's Insight
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Teferi's Time Twist
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Serum Snare
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Hide on the Ceiling
6.3%inclusion1 decks16 decks
5%synergy
Eureka Moment
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
-6%synergy
Reject Imperfection
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Wrap in Vigor
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Archdruid's Charm
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
0%synergy
Krosan Grip
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
-1%synergy
Flare of Denial
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Sorceries
Cultivate
42%inclusion15 decks36 decks
-5%synergy
Rishkar's Expertise
39%inclusion14 decks36 decks
30%synergy
Wave Goodbye
36%inclusion13 decks36 decks
25%synergy
Windfall
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
21%synergy
Nature's Lore
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
-7%synergy
Tezzeret's Gambit
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
21%synergy
Enter the Enigma
23%inclusion8 decks35 decks
21%synergy
Give // Take
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
21%synergy
Explore
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Contentious Plan
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
17%synergy
Three Visits
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
-8%synergy
Sea Gate Restoration
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
11%synergy
Curse of the Swine
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Fangs of Kalonia
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
15%synergy
Bala Ged Recovery
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Ponder
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Farseek
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
-12%synergy
Broken Bond
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
9%synergy
Smell Fear
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
13%synergy
Overwhelming Stampede
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Pir's Whim
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
10%synergy
Splash Portal
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Flood of Tears
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
9%synergy
Search for Tomorrow
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Preordain
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Carnivorous Canopy
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
10%synergy
Season of Gathering
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Treasure Cruise
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Bridgeworks Battle
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Thirsting Roots
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Combat Tutorial
8.3%inclusion2 decks24 decks
8%synergy
Shared Roots
8.3%inclusion1 decks12 decks
3%synergy
Chart a Course
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Unnatural Restoration
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Gitaxian Probe
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
4%synergy
The Crowd Goes Wild
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Slip Through Space
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Oversimplify
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
1%synergy
Neoform
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Season of Weaving
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Tempt with Discovery
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
1%synergy
Commit // Memory
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Ideas Unbound
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Harmonize
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
0%synergy
Artful Dodge
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Urban Evolution
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
-4%synergy
Vivisurgeon's Insight
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Compulsive Research
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Venom Blast
5.3%inclusion1 decks19 decks
5%synergy
Utility Artifacts
Swiftfoot Boots
36%inclusion13 decks36 decks
11%synergy
The Ozolith
33%inclusion12 decks36 decks
27%synergy
Lightning Greaves
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
-4%synergy
The Earth Crystal
17%inclusion4 decks24 decks
11%synergy
The Great Henge
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Umezawa's Jitte
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Whispersilk Cloak
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Blitzball Stadium
8.3%inclusion2 decks24 decks
8%synergy
Power Conduit
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Bow of Nylea
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Teferi's Puzzle Box
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Contagion Clasp
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Perilous Vault
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Bone Sabres
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Shadowspear
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Transmogrifying Wand
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Dragon Throne of Tarkir
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
The Magic Mirror
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Explorer's Cache
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Conjurer's Closet
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Howling Mine
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Enchantments
Hadana's Climb
33%inclusion12 decks36 decks
30%synergy
Terrasymbiosis
29%inclusion6 decks21 decks
22%synergy
Innkeeper's Talent
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
20%synergy
Sphere Grid
25%inclusion6 decks24 decks
21%synergy
Master Chef
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
21%synergy
Proft's Eidetic Memory
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
20%synergy
Primal Empathy
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
14%synergy
Bred for the Hunt
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
12%synergy
Doubling Season
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
1%synergy
Teferi's Ageless Insight
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Court of Garenbrig
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
9%synergy
Sylvan Library
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Loading Zone
11%inclusion2 decks19 decks
8%synergy
Fight Rigging
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Hydra's Growth
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Ominous Seas
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Wild Growth
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
0%synergy
Rancor
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
6%synergy
As Foretold
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Utopia Sprawl
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
-1%synergy
Inexorable Tide
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
2%synergy
On the Trail
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Curse of Predation
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
The Phasing of Zhalfir
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Rites of Flourishing
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Tribute to the World Tree
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
0%synergy
Mystic Remora
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
-9%synergy
Communal Brewing
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Kenrith's Transformation
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Death's Presence
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Greater Good
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Shielding Plax
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Propaganda
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
-1%synergy
Candlekeep Sage
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Planeswalkers
Jace, Wielder of Mysteries
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
18%synergy
Teferi, Temporal Pilgrim
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
18%synergy
Jiang Yanggu, Wildcrafter
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
16%synergy
Oko, Thief of Crowns
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Jace, the Mind Sculptor
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Teferi, Master of Time
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Jace, Arcane Strategist
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Vivien, Nature's Avenger
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Nissa, Who Shakes the World
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Utility Lands
Reliquary Tower
75%inclusion27 decks36 decks
25%synergy
Rogue's Passage
58%inclusion21 decks36 decks
36%synergy
Karn's Bastion
31%inclusion11 decks36 decks
20%synergy
Oran-Rief, the Vastwood
31%inclusion11 decks36 decks
25%synergy
Novijen, Heart of Progress
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
21%synergy
Alchemist's Refuge
22%inclusion8 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Boseiju, Who Endures
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
-3%synergy
Nesting Grounds
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
16%synergy
Otawara, Soaring City
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
1%synergy
Mosswort Bridge
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
-1%synergy
Llanowar Reborn
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
9%synergy
Forge of Heroes
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
11%synergy
Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
-10%synergy
Mistrise Village
10%inclusion3 decks31 decks
-1%synergy
Restless Vinestalk
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Mystic Sanctuary
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
-4%synergy
Tranquil Thicket
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Blast Zone
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Lonely Sandbar
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Lumbering Falls
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
-1%synergy
Cephalid Coliseum
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Temple of the False God
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
-10%synergy
Mana Artifacts
Sol Ring
86%inclusion31 decks36 decks
6%synergy
Arcane Signet
64%inclusion23 decks36 decks
1%synergy
Thought Vessel
44%inclusion16 decks36 decks
25%synergy
Simic Signet
33%inclusion12 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Talisman of Curiosity
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
-2%synergy
Everflowing Chalice
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
13%synergy
Decanter of Endless Water
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
9%synergy
Midnight Clock
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
12%synergy
Commander's Sphere
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Staff of Compleation
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
10%synergy
Astral Cornucopia
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Mind Stone
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Aetheric Amplifier
5.9%inclusion2 decks34 decks
5%synergy
Replicating Ring
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Empowered Autogenerator
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Fellwar Stone
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
-4%synergy
Lands
Island
100%inclusion36 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Forest
100%inclusion36 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Command Tower
89%inclusion32 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Simic Growth Chamber
72%inclusion26 decks36 decks
25%synergy
Hinterland Harbor
69%inclusion25 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Yavimaya Coast
61%inclusion22 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Temple of Mystery
53%inclusion19 decks36 decks
15%synergy
Breeding Pool
50%inclusion18 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Vineglimmer Snarl
47%inclusion17 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Rejuvenating Springs
47%inclusion17 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Flooded Grove
47%inclusion17 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Dreamroot Cascade
47%inclusion17 decks36 decks
3%synergy
Barkchannel Pathway
36%inclusion13 decks36 decks
16%synergy
Waterlogged Grove
36%inclusion13 decks36 decks
17%synergy
Exotic Orchard
33%inclusion12 decks36 decks
9%synergy
Sodden Verdure
33%inclusion2 decks6 decks
15%synergy
Willowrush Verge
29%inclusion10 decks34 decks
11%synergy
Tangled Islet
28%inclusion10 decks36 decks
12%synergy
Overflowing Basin
28%inclusion10 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Opal Palace
28%inclusion10 decks36 decks
25%synergy
Misty Rainforest
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
-6%synergy
Hedge Maze
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Thornwood Falls
25%inclusion9 decks36 decks
8%synergy
Botanical Sanctum
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Evolving Wilds
19%inclusion7 decks36 decks
-5%synergy
Terramorphic Expanse
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
-3%synergy
Vivid Creek
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
15%synergy
Sea Gate Restoration
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
11%synergy
Vivid Grove
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
15%synergy
Sink into Stupor
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Bala Ged Recovery
17%inclusion6 decks36 decks
7%synergy
Fabled Passage
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
-2%synergy
Disciple of Freyalise
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
9%synergy
Simic Guildgate
14%inclusion5 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Myriad Landscape
11%inclusion4 decks36 decks
-10%synergy
Littjara Mirrorlake
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
5%synergy
Tropical Island
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
-6%synergy
Bridgeworks Battle
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Path of Ancestry
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
-9%synergy
Scalding Tarn
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
-1%synergy
Meditation Pools
8.3%inclusion1 decks12 decks
7%synergy
Woodland Stream
8.3%inclusion3 decks36 decks
4%synergy
Lakeside Shack
5.7%inclusion2 decks35 decks
4%synergy
Blighted Woodland
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
-1%synergy
Hydroelectric Specimen
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
0%synergy
Ash Barrens
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
2%synergy
Verdant Catacombs
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
-3%synergy
Rimewood Falls
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
-3%synergy
Gemstone Caverns
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
0%synergy
Mirrodin's Core
5.6%inclusion2 decks36 decks
5%synergy