Pir, Imaginative Rascal // Toothy, Imaginary Friend (Commander) - Expensive +1/+1 Counters

Tyler Bucks
Mar 17, 2026
Budget Replacements for Doubling Season in Commander
Doubling Season is one of the most well known cards for Commander players. But it's expensive! Let's look at some cheaper alternatives.
Deck Filters
Archidekt
Commander Spellbook
Moxfield
Scryfall
MTGStocks
Spaceshift
100%inclusion2 decks2 decks
100%synergy
Iron Man, Armored Avenger
67%inclusion2 decks3 decks
64%synergy
High Synergy Cards
Brainstorm
71%inclusion40 decks56 decks
57%synergy
Sylvan Library
63%inclusion35 decks56 decks
54%synergy
Hardened Scales
70%inclusion39 decks56 decks
52%synergy
Essence Flux
55%inclusion31 decks56 decks
52%synergy
The Ozolith
59%inclusion33 decks56 decks
52%synergy
Boseiju, Who Endures
71%inclusion40 decks56 decks
49%synergy
Displacer Kitten
52%inclusion29 decks56 decks
49%synergy
Laboratory Maniac
55%inclusion31 decks56 decks
49%synergy
Kami of Whispered Hopes
55%inclusion31 decks56 decks
47%synergy
Windfall
50%inclusion28 decks56 decks
46%synergy
Top Cards
Birds of Paradise
61%inclusion34 decks56 decks
33%synergy
The Great Henge
54%inclusion30 decks56 decks
44%synergy
Swan Song
54%inclusion30 decks56 decks
35%synergy
Force of Negation
54%inclusion30 decks56 decks
46%synergy
Mystic Remora
52%inclusion29 decks56 decks
38%synergy
Forgotten Ancient
50%inclusion28 decks56 decks
40%synergy
Mana Drain
48%inclusion27 decks56 decks
33%synergy
Branching Evolution
46%inclusion26 decks56 decks
34%synergy
Jace, Wielder of Mysteries
46%inclusion26 decks56 decks
42%synergy
Eternal Witness
43%inclusion24 decks56 decks
24%synergy
Game Changers
Rhystic Study
80%inclusion45 decks56 decks
61%synergy
Cyclonic Rift
71%inclusion40 decks56 decks
48%synergy
Fierce Guardianship
66%inclusion37 decks56 decks
50%synergy
Ancient Tomb
61%inclusion34 decks56 decks
52%synergy
Force of Will
54%inclusion30 decks56 decks
45%synergy
The One Ring
52%inclusion29 decks56 decks
45%synergy
Mystical Tutor
50%inclusion28 decks56 decks
42%synergy
Gaea's Cradle
48%inclusion27 decks56 decks
42%synergy
Worldly Tutor
43%inclusion24 decks56 decks
29%synergy
Chrome Mox
41%inclusion23 decks56 decks
35%synergy
Creatures
Kodama of the West Tree
41%inclusion23 decks56 decks
37%synergy
Wan Shi Tong, Librarian
39%inclusion7 decks18 decks
32%synergy
Herald of Secret Streams
38%inclusion21 decks56 decks
23%synergy
Bristly Bill, Spine Sower
38%inclusion21 decks56 decks
33%synergy
Managorger Hydra
36%inclusion20 decks56 decks
31%synergy
Evolution Sage
36%inclusion20 decks56 decks
26%synergy
Fathom Mage
32%inclusion18 decks56 decks
25%synergy
Deepglow Skate
32%inclusion18 decks56 decks
30%synergy
Gyre Sage
32%inclusion18 decks56 decks
26%synergy
Delighted Halfling
32%inclusion18 decks56 decks
21%synergy
Consecrated Sphinx
30%inclusion17 decks56 decks
22%synergy
Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider
30%inclusion17 decks56 decks
28%synergy
Llanowar Elves
30%inclusion17 decks56 decks
3%synergy
Chasm Skulker
30%inclusion17 decks56 decks
24%synergy
Incubation Druid
29%inclusion16 decks56 decks
21%synergy
Faerie Mastermind
29%inclusion16 decks56 decks
23%synergy
Rishkar, Peema Renegade
27%inclusion15 decks56 decks
22%synergy
Kalonian Hydra
27%inclusion15 decks56 decks
23%synergy
Ledger Shredder
27%inclusion15 decks56 decks
25%synergy
Pollywog Prodigy
26%inclusion14 decks54 decks
20%synergy
Twenty-Toed Toad
26%inclusion14 decks54 decks
20%synergy
Vorel of the Hull Clade
25%inclusion14 decks56 decks
17%synergy
Fyndhorn Elves
23%inclusion13 decks56 decks
9%synergy
Phyrexian Metamorph
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
13%synergy
Elvish Mystic
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
-1%synergy
Seedborn Muse
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Master Biomancer
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
15%synergy
Walking Ballista
20%inclusion11 decks56 decks
15%synergy
Dreamtide Whale
20%inclusion11 decks56 decks
16%synergy
Disciple of Freyalise
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
13%synergy
Prime Speaker Zegana
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
8%synergy
Hullbreaker Horror
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
0%synergy
Evolution Witness
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
12%synergy
Thassa's Oracle
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
12%synergy
Psychosis Crawler
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
12%synergy
Spellseeker
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
14%synergy
Vigor
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
14%synergy
Kinnan, Bonder Prodigy
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
13%synergy
Champion of Lambholt
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
11%synergy
Thrummingbird
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
11%synergy
Zimone, Paradox Sculptor
15%inclusion6 decks39 decks
10%synergy
Elvish Spirit Guide
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
10%synergy
Flux Channeler
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
12%synergy
Spark Double
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Pensive Professor
14%inclusion1 decks7 decks
9%synergy
Yavimaya Bloomsage
14%inclusion1 decks7 decks
10%synergy
Topiary Lecturer
14%inclusion1 decks7 decks
11%synergy
Gilded Drake
13%inclusion7 decks56 decks
11%synergy
Endurance
13%inclusion7 decks56 decks
8%synergy
Ouroboroid
11%inclusion3 decks27 decks
7%synergy
Instants
Planar Incision
43%inclusion24 decks56 decks
41%synergy
Ghostly Flicker
43%inclusion24 decks56 decks
37%synergy
Heroic Intervention
39%inclusion22 decks56 decks
9%synergy
Veil of Summer
34%inclusion19 decks56 decks
29%synergy
Pongify
34%inclusion19 decks56 decks
9%synergy
Noxious Revival
34%inclusion19 decks56 decks
29%synergy
Beast Within
32%inclusion18 decks56 decks
-16%synergy
Counterspell
32%inclusion18 decks56 decks
-17%synergy
Frantic Search
30%inclusion17 decks56 decks
24%synergy
An Offer You Can't Refuse
30%inclusion17 decks56 decks
7%synergy
Inspiring Call
30%inclusion17 decks56 decks
17%synergy
Pact of Negation
30%inclusion17 decks56 decks
24%synergy
Growth Spiral
27%inclusion15 decks56 decks
-18%synergy
Flusterstorm
25%inclusion14 decks56 decks
19%synergy
Crop Rotation
23%inclusion13 decks56 decks
11%synergy
Arcane Denial
23%inclusion13 decks56 decks
1%synergy
Siren's Ruse
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
21%synergy
Sink into Stupor
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
9%synergy
Mental Misstep
20%inclusion11 decks56 decks
15%synergy
Chain of Vapor
20%inclusion11 decks56 decks
17%synergy
Rapid Hybridization
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
-9%synergy
Muddle the Mixture
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
14%synergy
Mindbreak Trap
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
13%synergy
Force of Vigor
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
14%synergy
Nature's Claim
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
9%synergy
Snap
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
12%synergy
Ripples of Potential
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Tolarian Winds
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
14%synergy
March of Swirling Mist
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
11%synergy
Nexus Mentality
14%inclusion1 decks7 decks
9%synergy
Strix Serenade
13%inclusion7 decks56 decks
10%synergy
Borne Upon a Wind
13%inclusion7 decks56 decks
11%synergy
Mutational Advantage
11%inclusion6 decks56 decks
6%synergy
Displace
11%inclusion6 decks56 decks
9%synergy
Blue Sun's Zenith
11%inclusion6 decks56 decks
7%synergy
Chord of Calling
11%inclusion6 decks56 decks
3%synergy
Blur
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
7%synergy
Repulsive Mutation
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
3%synergy
Resculpt
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Snakeskin Veil
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
1%synergy
Return of the Wildspeaker
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
-3%synergy
Solidarity of Heroes
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
7%synergy
Legolas's Quick Reflexes
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
6%synergy
Opt
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
-0%synergy
Delay
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Misdirection
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Teferi's Time Twist
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
6%synergy
Gush
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Intuition
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Bioshift
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Sorceries
Gitaxian Probe
36%inclusion20 decks56 decks
34%synergy
Sea Gate Restoration
36%inclusion20 decks56 decks
30%synergy
Finale of Devastation
34%inclusion19 decks56 decks
23%synergy
Eldritch Evolution
32%inclusion18 decks56 decks
29%synergy
Three Visits
30%inclusion17 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Nature's Lore
29%inclusion16 decks56 decks
-4%synergy
Neoform
27%inclusion15 decks56 decks
24%synergy
Ponder
25%inclusion14 decks56 decks
18%synergy
Tezzeret's Gambit
25%inclusion14 decks56 decks
21%synergy
Timetwister
25%inclusion14 decks56 decks
25%synergy
Wave Goodbye
23%inclusion13 decks56 decks
12%synergy
Cultivate
23%inclusion13 decks56 decks
-23%synergy
Preordain
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
10%synergy
Kodama's Reach
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
-18%synergy
Echo of Eons
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
16%synergy
Rishkar's Expertise
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
7%synergy
Splash Portal
15%inclusion8 decks54 decks
12%synergy
Careful Study
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
14%synergy
Farseek
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
-12%synergy
Rampant Growth
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
-25%synergy
Bridgeworks Battle
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
10%synergy
Bala Ged Recovery
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Enter the Enigma
14%inclusion6 decks43 decks
12%synergy
Nature's Rhythm
13%inclusion4 decks30 decks
7%synergy
Green Sun's Zenith
13%inclusion7 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Give // Take
13%inclusion7 decks56 decks
12%synergy
Season of Gathering
11%inclusion6 decks55 decks
9%synergy
Treasure Cruise
11%inclusion6 decks56 decks
7%synergy
Explore
11%inclusion6 decks56 decks
-9%synergy
Merchant Scroll
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
8%synergy
Sylvan Tutor
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
7%synergy
Solve the Equation
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
7%synergy
Contentious Plan
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Last March of the Ents
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Time Spiral
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
7%synergy
Lórien Revealed
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
3%synergy
Fangs of Kalonia
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
3%synergy
Personal Tutor
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Time Warp
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
3%synergy
Regrowth
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
2%synergy
Utility Artifacts
Ozolith, the Shattered Spire
41%inclusion23 decks56 decks
33%synergy
Sensei's Divining Top
25%inclusion14 decks56 decks
21%synergy
Agatha's Soul Cauldron
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
16%synergy
Swiftfoot Boots
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
-7%synergy
Teferi's Puzzle Box
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
16%synergy
Sword of Truth and Justice
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
14%synergy
Lightning Greaves
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
-6%synergy
Andúril, Narsil Reforged
11%inclusion6 decks56 decks
10%synergy
Shadowspear
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
8%synergy
Ichormoon Gauntlet
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
6%synergy
Conjurer's Closet
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Spellbook
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Isochron Scepter
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
3%synergy
Sapphire Medallion
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
2%synergy
Birthing Pod
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Enchantments
Simic Ascendancy
43%inclusion24 decks56 decks
29%synergy
Wizard Class
38%inclusion21 decks56 decks
32%synergy
Terrasymbiosis
33%inclusion9 decks27 decks
26%synergy
Innkeeper's Talent
31%inclusion17 decks55 decks
25%synergy
Proft's Eidetic Memory
29%inclusion16 decks56 decks
26%synergy
Sphere Grid
26%inclusion7 decks27 decks
22%synergy
Doubling Season
23%inclusion13 decks56 decks
13%synergy
Court of Garenbrig
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
19%synergy
Carpet of Flowers
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
19%synergy
Wild Growth
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
13%synergy
Hadana's Climb
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
18%synergy
Inexorable Tide
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
15%synergy
Exploration
13%inclusion7 decks56 decks
-0%synergy
Burgeoning
13%inclusion7 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Utopia Sprawl
11%inclusion6 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Master Chef
11%inclusion6 decks56 decks
10%synergy
Level Up
10%inclusion1 decks10 decks
8%synergy
High Score
10%inclusion1 decks10 decks
8%synergy
Communal Brewing
7.4%inclusion4 decks54 decks
6%synergy
Freed from the Real
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
3%synergy
Survival of the Fittest
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Garruk's Uprising
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
-12%synergy
Hydra's Growth
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Song of the Dryads
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Copy Artifact
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Leyline of Anticipation
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
1%synergy
Kenrith's Transformation
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
2%synergy
Pemmin's Aura
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
2%synergy
Dress Down
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Greater Good
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
3%synergy
As Foretold
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Bred for the Hunt
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
0%synergy
Concordant Crossroads
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
2%synergy
Battles
Invasion of Ikoria
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Planeswalkers
Oko, Thief of Crowns
25%inclusion14 decks56 decks
19%synergy
Teferi, Master of Time
25%inclusion14 decks56 decks
24%synergy
Teferi, Temporal Pilgrim
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
15%synergy
Jace, the Mind Sculptor
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
15%synergy
Narset, Parter of Veils
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
15%synergy
Kiora, the Crashing Wave
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
3%synergy
Nissa, Voice of Zendikar
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Kaito, Cunning Infiltrator
5.1%inclusion2 decks39 decks
5%synergy
Utility Lands
Reliquary Tower
75%inclusion42 decks56 decks
25%synergy
Otawara, Soaring City
59%inclusion33 decks56 decks
40%synergy
Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth
48%inclusion27 decks56 decks
27%synergy
Rogue's Passage
38%inclusion21 decks56 decks
14%synergy
Karn's Bastion
32%inclusion18 decks56 decks
21%synergy
Minamo, School at Water's Edge
30%inclusion17 decks56 decks
25%synergy
Urza's Saga
27%inclusion15 decks56 decks
22%synergy
Alchemist's Refuge
23%inclusion13 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Cephalid Coliseum
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
18%synergy
Mystic Sanctuary
20%inclusion11 decks56 decks
8%synergy
Emergence Zone
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
11%synergy
Shifting Woodland
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
9%synergy
Mistrise Village
13%inclusion4 decks30 decks
2%synergy
Oran-Rief, the Vastwood
13%inclusion7 decks56 decks
6%synergy
Novijen, Heart of Progress
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
5%synergy
City of Traitors
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
8%synergy
Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Llanowar Reborn
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
2%synergy
Homeward Path
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
6%synergy
Rivendell
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
0%synergy
Lonely Sandbar
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
2%synergy
Forge of Heroes
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Dryad Arbor
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
1%synergy
Mana Artifacts
Sol Ring
95%inclusion53 decks56 decks
14%synergy
Arcane Signet
77%inclusion43 decks56 decks
14%synergy
Talisman of Curiosity
45%inclusion25 decks56 decks
23%synergy
Thought Vessel
39%inclusion22 decks56 decks
19%synergy
Mana Vault
36%inclusion20 decks56 decks
30%synergy
Mox Diamond
36%inclusion20 decks56 decks
31%synergy
Lotus Petal
30%inclusion17 decks56 decks
24%synergy
Simic Signet
25%inclusion14 decks56 decks
-5%synergy
Mox Opal
25%inclusion14 decks56 decks
21%synergy
Mox Amber
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
16%synergy
Fellwar Stone
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
12%synergy
Grim Monolith
16%inclusion9 decks56 decks
13%synergy
Mana Crypt
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
14%synergy
Everflowing Chalice
11%inclusion6 decks56 decks
7%synergy
Jeweled Lotus
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
9%synergy
Basalt Monolith
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
2%synergy
Astral Cornucopia
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Machine God's Effigy
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Decanter of Endless Water
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
1%synergy
Midnight Clock
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
3%synergy
Lands
Breeding Pool
96%inclusion54 decks56 decks
49%synergy
Island
93%inclusion52 decks56 decks
-3%synergy
Forest
91%inclusion51 decks56 decks
-5%synergy
Command Tower
89%inclusion50 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Misty Rainforest
89%inclusion50 decks56 decks
58%synergy
Tropical Island
84%inclusion47 decks56 decks
70%synergy
Rejuvenating Springs
75%inclusion42 decks56 decks
33%synergy
Yavimaya Coast
61%inclusion34 decks56 decks
8%synergy
Waterlogged Grove
57%inclusion32 decks56 decks
38%synergy
Hinterland Harbor
55%inclusion31 decks56 decks
-6%synergy
Dreamroot Cascade
43%inclusion24 decks56 decks
-3%synergy
Barkchannel Pathway
39%inclusion22 decks56 decks
20%synergy
Hedge Maze
39%inclusion22 decks56 decks
20%synergy
Wooded Foothills
38%inclusion21 decks56 decks
28%synergy
Scalding Tarn
38%inclusion21 decks56 decks
28%synergy
Sea Gate Restoration
36%inclusion20 decks56 decks
30%synergy
Verdant Catacombs
36%inclusion20 decks56 decks
27%synergy
Polluted Delta
36%inclusion20 decks56 decks
26%synergy
Flooded Strand
36%inclusion20 decks56 decks
25%synergy
Exotic Orchard
34%inclusion19 decks56 decks
9%synergy
Gemstone Caverns
34%inclusion19 decks56 decks
28%synergy
Windswept Heath
32%inclusion18 decks56 decks
22%synergy
Mana Confluence
32%inclusion18 decks56 decks
27%synergy
Flooded Grove
32%inclusion18 decks56 decks
-11%synergy
Botanical Sanctum
29%inclusion16 decks56 decks
16%synergy
Turbulent Wilderness
29%inclusion2 decks7 decks
11%synergy
City of Brass
27%inclusion15 decks56 decks
21%synergy
Prismatic Vista
25%inclusion14 decks56 decks
18%synergy
Vineglimmer Snarl
25%inclusion14 decks56 decks
-15%synergy
Willowrush Verge
25%inclusion8 decks32 decks
7%synergy
Sink into Stupor
21%inclusion12 decks56 decks
9%synergy
Simic Growth Chamber
20%inclusion11 decks56 decks
-26%synergy
Disciple of Freyalise
18%inclusion10 decks56 decks
13%synergy
Snow-Covered Island
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
8%synergy
Snow-Covered Forest
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
9%synergy
Bridgeworks Battle
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
10%synergy
Bala Ged Recovery
14%inclusion8 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Fabled Passage
11%inclusion6 decks56 decks
-6%synergy
Opal Palace
11%inclusion6 decks56 decks
7%synergy
Reflecting Pool
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
6%synergy
Cavern of Souls
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
4%synergy
Glasspool Mimic
8.9%inclusion5 decks56 decks
5%synergy
Starting Town
7.4%inclusion2 decks27 decks
6%synergy
Hydroelectric Specimen
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
1%synergy
Overflowing Basin
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
-15%synergy
Temple of Mystery
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
-30%synergy
Rimewood Falls
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
-1%synergy
Evolving Wilds
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
-17%synergy
Forbidden Orchard
7.1%inclusion4 decks56 decks
6%synergy
Tangled Islet
5.4%inclusion3 decks56 decks
-10%synergy