Withar, Cocoon Keeper (Commander)

Original Name:

Mister NegativeMister Negative

Background image for The EDHREC Writers' Favorite New Commanders of 2025
Andy Zupke
Dec 11, 2025
The EDHREC Writers' Favorite New Commanders of 2025
The writing staff at EDHREC gives you the rundown on their favorite new commanders that came out in 2025. Is your favorite on the list?
Deck Filters
Cardsphere
Archidekt
Commander Spellbook
Moxfield
Scryfall
MTGStocks
Personify
7.2%inclusion45 decks628 decks
4%synergy
Abigale, Eloquent First-Year
2.1%inclusion13 decks628 decks
-1%synergy
Curious Colossus
1.9%inclusion12 decks628 decks
1%synergy
Madame Null, Power Broker
1.3%inclusion5 decks371 decks
1%synergy
Morningtide's Light
1.1%inclusion30 decks2.77K decks
0%synergy
High Synergy Cards
Ephemerate
79%inclusion2.96K decks3.75K decks
72%synergy
Cloudshift
72%inclusion2.71K decks3.75K decks
67%synergy
Wall of Blood
58%inclusion2.17K decks3.75K decks
57%synergy
Children of Korlis
57%inclusion2.14K decks3.75K decks
53%synergy
Tainted Remedy
55%inclusion2.07K decks3.75K decks
53%synergy
Conjurer's Closet
56%inclusion2.10K decks3.75K decks
52%synergy
Enduring Tenacity
63%inclusion2.35K decks3.75K decks
51%synergy
Teleportation Circle
55%inclusion2.07K decks3.75K decks
51%synergy
Flicker of Fate
53%inclusion2K decks3.75K decks
50%synergy
Toxic Deluge
66%inclusion2.48K decks3.75K decks
49%synergy
Top Cards
Swords to Plowshares
76%inclusion2.86K decks3.75K decks
12%synergy
Vito, Thorn of the Dusk Rose
63%inclusion2.37K decks3.75K decks
41%synergy
Anguished Unmaking
58%inclusion2.17K decks3.75K decks
18%synergy
Black Market Connections
57%inclusion2.15K decks3.75K decks
36%synergy
Dark Ritual
55%inclusion2.06K decks3.75K decks
32%synergy
Sanguine Bond
53%inclusion1.99K decks3.75K decks
32%synergy
Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff
53%inclusion1.99K decks3.75K decks
33%synergy
Phyrexian Arena
51%inclusion1.92K decks3.75K decks
22%synergy
Path to Exile
48%inclusion1.81K decks3.75K decks
-1%synergy
K'rrik, Son of Yawgmoth
47%inclusion1.75K decks3.75K decks
44%synergy
Game Changers
Bolas's Citadel
46%inclusion1.73K decks3.75K decks
32%synergy
Necropotence
29%inclusion1.07K decks3.75K decks
22%synergy
Smothering Tithe
24%inclusion910 decks3.75K decks
1%synergy
Ancient Tomb
19%inclusion719 decks3.75K decks
13%synergy
Teferi's Protection
17%inclusion627 decks3.75K decks
1%synergy
Demonic Tutor
16%inclusion600 decks3.75K decks
0%synergy
The One Ring
15%inclusion580 decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Vampiric Tutor
13%inclusion474 decks3.75K decks
1%synergy
Ad Nauseam
12%inclusion457 decks3.75K decks
10%synergy
Enlightened Tutor
9.0%inclusion338 decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Creatures
Tree of Perdition
46%inclusion1.74K decks3.75K decks
45%synergy
Dark Confidant
46%inclusion1.74K decks3.75K decks
40%synergy
Gray Merchant of Asphodel
45%inclusion1.70K decks3.75K decks
34%synergy
Solemn Simulacrum
42%inclusion1.56K decks3.75K decks
26%synergy
Gwenom, Remorseless
39%inclusion1.46K decks3.75K decks
37%synergy
Astarion, the Decadent
39%inclusion1.46K decks3.75K decks
33%synergy
Charming Prince
38%inclusion1.43K decks3.75K decks
34%synergy
Bloodletter of Aclazotz
38%inclusion1.42K decks3.75K decks
30%synergy
Soul Warden
37%inclusion1.38K decks3.75K decks
19%synergy
Witch Enchanter
33%inclusion1.25K decks3.75K decks
22%synergy
Platinum Angel
33%inclusion1.24K decks3.75K decks
32%synergy
Doom Whisperer
32%inclusion1.21K decks3.75K decks
31%synergy
Vizkopa Guildmage
32%inclusion1.18K decks3.75K decks
25%synergy
Blood Celebrant
30%inclusion1.11K decks3.75K decks
29%synergy
Phelia, Exuberant Shepherd
28%inclusion1.05K decks3.75K decks
24%synergy
Flickerwisp
28%inclusion1.04K decks3.75K decks
24%synergy
Soul's Attendant
27%inclusion1.01K decks3.75K decks
14%synergy
Restoration Angel
26%inclusion994 decks3.75K decks
23%synergy
Crypt Ghast
26%inclusion965 decks3.75K decks
18%synergy
Plague Drone
26%inclusion964 decks3.75K decks
25%synergy
Kambal, Consul of Allocation
25%inclusion940 decks3.75K decks
10%synergy
Sheoldred, the Apocalypse
25%inclusion934 decks3.75K decks
18%synergy
Esper Sentinel
24%inclusion907 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Bloodthirsty Conqueror
23%inclusion868 decks3.75K decks
13%synergy
Knight of the White Orchid
22%inclusion828 decks3.75K decks
14%synergy
Darkstar Augur
22%inclusion827 decks3.75K decks
17%synergy
Psychosis Crawler
21%inclusion804 decks3.75K decks
21%synergy
Loran of the Third Path
21%inclusion799 decks3.75K decks
13%synergy
Vilis, Broker of Blood
20%inclusion732 decks3.75K decks
17%synergy
Grand Abolisher
19%inclusion720 decks3.75K decks
10%synergy
Herald of Eternal Dawn
19%inclusion711 decks3.75K decks
17%synergy
Boggart Trawler
18%inclusion677 decks3.75K decks
11%synergy
Keen Duelist
18%inclusion672 decks3.75K decks
15%synergy
Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines
17%inclusion654 decks3.75K decks
14%synergy
Suture Priest
17%inclusion646 decks3.75K decks
3%synergy
Rhox Faithmender
17%inclusion637 decks3.75K decks
12%synergy
Sorin of House Markov
15%inclusion548 decks3.75K decks
10%synergy
Claim Jumper
14%inclusion521 decks3.75K decks
11%synergy
Evra, Halcyon Witness
13%inclusion494 decks3.75K decks
13%synergy
Haliya, Guided by Light
13%inclusion485 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Serra Ascendant
12%inclusion465 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim
12%inclusion453 decks3.75K decks
-23%synergy
Distinguished Conjurer
12%inclusion433 decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Felidar Guardian
11%inclusion421 decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Blood Artist
10%inclusion378 decks3.75K decks
-21%synergy
Loyal Warhound
10%inclusion358 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Gilraen, Dúnedain Protector
9.3%inclusion349 decks3.75K decks
8%synergy
Ravenous Chupacabra
9.0%inclusion339 decks3.75K decks
7%synergy
The Spot, Living Portal
8.4%inclusion317 decks3.75K decks
8%synergy
Wall of Omens
8.1%inclusion303 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Instants
Parting Gust
39%inclusion1.46K decks3.75K decks
35%synergy
Angel's Grace
38%inclusion1.41K decks3.75K decks
35%synergy
Malakir Rebirth
29%inclusion1.09K decks3.75K decks
18%synergy
Eerie Interlude
28%inclusion1.06K decks3.75K decks
23%synergy
Despark
28%inclusion1.04K decks3.75K decks
-3%synergy
Fell the Profane
25%inclusion930 decks3.75K decks
12%synergy
Inkshield
23%inclusion846 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Stinging Study
22%inclusion815 decks3.75K decks
20%synergy
False Cure
21%inclusion782 decks3.75K decks
20%synergy
Generous Gift
20%inclusion751 decks3.75K decks
-4%synergy
Imp's Mischief
20%inclusion748 decks3.75K decks
16%synergy
Stunning Reversal
18%inclusion693 decks3.75K decks
18%synergy
Justiciar's Portal
18%inclusion661 decks3.75K decks
17%synergy
Reprieve
17%inclusion635 decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Getaway Glamer
16%inclusion611 decks3.75K decks
15%synergy
Snuff Out
16%inclusion609 decks3.75K decks
15%synergy
Mortify
14%inclusion542 decks3.75K decks
-8%synergy
Infernal Grasp
14%inclusion508 decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Saw in Half
13%inclusion503 decks3.75K decks
10%synergy
Scrollshift
13%inclusion496 decks3.75K decks
12%synergy
Acrobatic Maneuver
12%inclusion466 decks3.75K decks
11%synergy
Slip On the Ring
11%inclusion411 decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Deadly Rollick
11%inclusion400 decks3.75K decks
0%synergy
Stroke of Midnight
10%inclusion386 decks3.75K decks
-4%synergy
Beacon of Immortality
10%inclusion382 decks3.75K decks
7%synergy
Withering Torment
10%inclusion362 decks3.75K decks
7%synergy
Silence
9.4%inclusion352 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Necrologia
9.0%inclusion339 decks3.75K decks
8%synergy
Heliod's Intervention
9.0%inclusion337 decks3.75K decks
4%synergy
Cabal Ritual
8.6%inclusion322 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Ghostway
8.1%inclusion304 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Rebuff the Wicked
7.8%inclusion294 decks3.75K decks
4%synergy
Bitter Triumph
7.4%inclusion279 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Lae'zel's Acrobatics
6.4%inclusion239 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Everybody Lives!
6.3%inclusion235 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Hatred
6.2%inclusion231 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Dawn Charm
6.1%inclusion230 decks3.75K decks
4%synergy
Flare of Fortitude
5.7%inclusion214 decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Courageous Resolve
5.4%inclusion203 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Airbender's Reversal
5.3%inclusion81 decks1.53K decks
4%synergy
The Spot's Portal
5.3%inclusion198 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Sorceries
Reanimate
44%inclusion1.65K decks3.75K decks
29%synergy
Night's Whisper
40%inclusion1.50K decks3.75K decks
23%synergy
Damn
38%inclusion1.43K decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Exsanguinate
38%inclusion1.42K decks3.75K decks
26%synergy
Sign in Blood
37%inclusion1.37K decks3.75K decks
19%synergy
Feed the Swarm
30%inclusion1.11K decks3.75K decks
22%synergy
Farewell
27%inclusion1K decks3.75K decks
14%synergy
Debt to the Deathless
25%inclusion951 decks3.75K decks
15%synergy
Repay in Kind
19%inclusion700 decks3.75K decks
18%synergy
Villainous Wrath
16%inclusion603 decks3.75K decks
15%synergy
Profane Transfusion
14%inclusion541 decks3.75K decks
14%synergy
Read the Bones
14%inclusion533 decks3.75K decks
4%synergy
Peer into the Abyss
13%inclusion472 decks3.75K decks
11%synergy
Fumigate
11%inclusion399 decks3.75K decks
3%synergy
Austere Command
10%inclusion393 decks3.75K decks
-8%synergy
Pain's Reward
10%inclusion391 decks3.75K decks
10%synergy
Vanquish the Horde
10%inclusion391 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Revival // Revenge
10%inclusion385 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Reverse the Sands
10%inclusion384 decks3.75K decks
10%synergy
Infernal Contract
9.4%inclusion354 decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Vindicate
9.4%inclusion351 decks3.75K decks
-3%synergy
Another Round
9.0%inclusion336 decks3.75K decks
7%synergy
Avatar's Wrath
8.4%inclusion136 decks1.62K decks
5%synergy
Insatiable Avarice
7.8%inclusion294 decks3.75K decks
4%synergy
Agadeem's Awakening
7.8%inclusion294 decks3.75K decks
3%synergy
Risky Research
6.8%inclusion254 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Blasphemous Edict
6.7%inclusion251 decks3.75K decks
1%synergy
Grim Tutor
6.7%inclusion251 decks3.75K decks
3%synergy
Damnation
6.5%inclusion244 decks3.75K decks
2%synergy
Wrath of God
5.8%inclusion219 decks3.75K decks
0%synergy
Temporal Extortion
5.2%inclusion194 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Flicker
5.0%inclusion188 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Utility Artifacts
Tainted Sigil
37%inclusion1.39K decks3.75K decks
34%synergy
Panharmonicon
29%inclusion1.10K decks3.75K decks
27%synergy
The Wind Crystal
29%inclusion1.08K decks3.75K decks
21%synergy
Pact Weapon
25%inclusion954 decks3.75K decks
24%synergy
Jet Medallion
22%inclusion810 decks3.75K decks
16%synergy
The Endstone
19%inclusion700 decks3.75K decks
18%synergy
Wayfarer's Bauble
18%inclusion670 decks3.75K decks
4%synergy
Aetherflux Reservoir
17%inclusion651 decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Archaeomancer's Map
17%inclusion638 decks3.75K decks
12%synergy
Pearl Medallion
14%inclusion532 decks3.75K decks
8%synergy
Phyrexian Processor
14%inclusion531 decks3.75K decks
14%synergy
Swiftfoot Boots
14%inclusion516 decks3.75K decks
-12%synergy
Alhammarret's Archive
12%inclusion449 decks3.75K decks
8%synergy
The Darkness Crystal
7.4%inclusion276 decks3.75K decks
3%synergy
Lightning Greaves
7.3%inclusion273 decks3.75K decks
-13%synergy
The Golden Throne
7.0%inclusion261 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Wedding Ring
6.9%inclusion258 decks3.75K decks
4%synergy
Soul Conduit
6.6%inclusion246 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Sensei's Divining Top
5.8%inclusion217 decks3.75K decks
3%synergy
Sword of Hearth and Home
5.6%inclusion211 decks3.75K decks
4%synergy
Enchantments
Phyrexian Unlife
40%inclusion1.51K decks3.75K decks
39%synergy
Authority of the Consuls
29%inclusion1.09K decks3.75K decks
14%synergy
Wound Reflection
27%inclusion1.01K decks3.75K decks
24%synergy
Exquisite Blood
26%inclusion989 decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Unspeakable Symbol
25%inclusion954 decks3.75K decks
25%synergy
Parker Luck
24%inclusion890 decks3.75K decks
22%synergy
Axis of Mortality
23%inclusion862 decks3.75K decks
22%synergy
Greed
21%inclusion805 decks3.75K decks
17%synergy
Blind Obedience
19%inclusion713 decks3.75K decks
1%synergy
Land Tax
18%inclusion657 decks3.75K decks
7%synergy
Ghostly Prison
17%inclusion638 decks3.75K decks
3%synergy
Touch the Spirit Realm
13%inclusion499 decks3.75K decks
11%synergy
Airbender Ascension
10%inclusion173 decks1.68K decks
7%synergy
Near-Death Experience
9.4%inclusion354 decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Dark Tutelage
9.4%inclusion352 decks3.75K decks
8%synergy
Necrodominance
7.6%inclusion286 decks3.75K decks
7%synergy
Trouble in Pairs
7.4%inclusion279 decks3.75K decks
2%synergy
Font of Agonies
7.0%inclusion263 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Phyrexian Reclamation
6.7%inclusion251 decks3.75K decks
2%synergy
Lunar Convocation
6.7%inclusion250 decks3.75K decks
-4%synergy
Glasswing Grace
6.1%inclusion230 decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Animate Dead
5.6%inclusion210 decks3.75K decks
-3%synergy
Bitterblossom
5.3%inclusion199 decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Planeswalkers
Sorin Markov
6.8%inclusion257 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Gideon of the Trials
6.7%inclusion250 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Utility Lands
Reliquary Tower
70%inclusion2.63K decks3.75K decks
47%synergy
Bojuka Bog
43%inclusion1.63K decks3.75K decks
0%synergy
Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth
36%inclusion1.34K decks3.75K decks
15%synergy
Cabal Coffers
26%inclusion958 decks3.75K decks
14%synergy
Vault of the Archangel
20%inclusion756 decks3.75K decks
-13%synergy
Temple of the False God
18%inclusion685 decks3.75K decks
10%synergy
Castle Locthwain
18%inclusion677 decks3.75K decks
8%synergy
Command Beacon
17%inclusion621 decks3.75K decks
13%synergy
War Room
15%inclusion545 decks3.75K decks
7%synergy
Multiversal Passage
10%inclusion393 decks3.75K decks
10%synergy
Takenuma, Abandoned Mire
10%inclusion359 decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Rogue's Passage
9.5%inclusion356 decks3.75K decks
-10%synergy
Eiganjo, Seat of the Empire
8.2%inclusion309 decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Hall of Heliod's Generosity
6.8%inclusion256 decks3.75K decks
-1%synergy
Urza's Saga
6.6%inclusion248 decks3.75K decks
1%synergy
Phyrexian Tower
6.1%inclusion230 decks3.75K decks
-10%synergy
Adagia, Windswept Bastion
5.2%inclusion196 decks3.75K decks
2%synergy
Mana Artifacts
Sol Ring
90%inclusion3.39K decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Arcane Signet
87%inclusion3.26K decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Talisman of Hierarchy
70%inclusion2.63K decks3.75K decks
17%synergy
Thought Vessel
67%inclusion2.52K decks3.75K decks
53%synergy
Orzhov Signet
56%inclusion2.10K decks3.75K decks
-1%synergy
Fellwar Stone
34%inclusion1.27K decks3.75K decks
13%synergy
Mind Stone
23%inclusion878 decks3.75K decks
-1%synergy
Decanter of Endless Water
23%inclusion866 decks3.75K decks
21%synergy
The Soul Stone
22%inclusion838 decks3.75K decks
17%synergy
Thran Dynamo
19%inclusion715 decks3.75K decks
17%synergy
Staff of Compleation
9.3%inclusion348 decks3.75K decks
7%synergy
Commander's Sphere
9.2%inclusion345 decks3.75K decks
-7%synergy
Gilded Lotus
9.2%inclusion344 decks3.75K decks
8%synergy
Phial of Galadriel
7.0%inclusion262 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Mana Vault
6.1%inclusion229 decks3.75K decks
4%synergy
Charcoal Diamond
6.0%inclusion225 decks3.75K decks
0%synergy
Worn Powerstone
5.9%inclusion223 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Marble Diamond
5.8%inclusion216 decks3.75K decks
0%synergy
Lands
Swamp
97%inclusion3.66K decks3.75K decks
0%synergy
Plains
97%inclusion3.65K decks3.75K decks
0%synergy
Command Tower
85%inclusion3.18K decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Godless Shrine
69%inclusion2.59K decks3.75K decks
19%synergy
Caves of Koilos
69%inclusion2.57K decks3.75K decks
11%synergy
Isolated Chapel
66%inclusion2.50K decks3.75K decks
1%synergy
Vault of Champions
48%inclusion1.82K decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Fetid Heath
46%inclusion1.72K decks3.75K decks
7%synergy
Marsh Flats
44%inclusion1.64K decks3.75K decks
14%synergy
Shattered Sanctum
43%inclusion1.63K decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Tainted Field
42%inclusion1.59K decks3.75K decks
-9%synergy
Orzhov Basilica
40%inclusion1.48K decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Bleachbone Verge
36%inclusion1.35K decks3.75K decks
14%synergy
Witch Enchanter
33%inclusion1.25K decks3.75K decks
22%synergy
Shadowy Backstreet
33%inclusion1.25K decks3.75K decks
11%synergy
Malakir Rebirth
29%inclusion1.09K decks3.75K decks
18%synergy
Shineshadow Snarl
29%inclusion1.09K decks3.75K decks
-12%synergy
Temple of Silence
27%inclusion1.02K decks3.75K decks
-13%synergy
Silent Clearing
26%inclusion982 decks3.75K decks
11%synergy
Exotic Orchard
26%inclusion975 decks3.75K decks
1%synergy
Brightclimb Pathway
25%inclusion932 decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Fell the Profane
25%inclusion930 decks3.75K decks
12%synergy
Desolate Mire
21%inclusion776 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Myriad Landscape
18%inclusion691 decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Boggart Trawler
18%inclusion677 decks3.75K decks
11%synergy
Scrubland
17%inclusion636 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Concealed Courtyard
16%inclusion617 decks3.75K decks
-4%synergy
Scoured Barrens
16%inclusion610 decks3.75K decks
-8%synergy
City of Brass
13%inclusion484 decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Mana Confluence
12%inclusion443 decks3.75K decks
9%synergy
Evolving Wilds
12%inclusion441 decks3.75K decks
-9%synergy
Sunlit Marsh
9.4%inclusion353 decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Bloodstained Mire
9.1%inclusion340 decks3.75K decks
3%synergy
Terramorphic Expanse
8.5%inclusion319 decks3.75K decks
-6%synergy
Polluted Delta
8.4%inclusion317 decks3.75K decks
3%synergy
Fabled Passage
8.2%inclusion309 decks3.75K decks
-1%synergy
Arid Mesa
8.1%inclusion305 decks3.75K decks
2%synergy
Prismatic Vista
8.1%inclusion304 decks3.75K decks
2%synergy
Path of Ancestry
7.9%inclusion298 decks3.75K decks
-16%synergy
Agadeem's Awakening
7.8%inclusion294 decks3.75K decks
3%synergy
Flooded Strand
7.6%inclusion286 decks3.75K decks
2%synergy
Cavern of Souls
7.6%inclusion284 decks3.75K decks
3%synergy
Verdant Catacombs
7.5%inclusion282 decks3.75K decks
2%synergy
Horizon of Progress
7.3%inclusion273 decks3.75K decks
6%synergy
Windswept Heath
7.1%inclusion268 decks3.75K decks
1%synergy
Glasswing Grace
6.1%inclusion230 decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Vibrant Cityscape
6.1%inclusion230 decks3.75K decks
5%synergy
Snowfield Sinkhole
6.1%inclusion228 decks3.75K decks
-2%synergy
Forlorn Flats
6.0%inclusion226 decks3.75K decks
1%synergy
Starting Town
5.7%inclusion212 decks3.75K decks
4%synergy